State Farm® Insurance Agent Joseph Benincasa
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Laura Pfister
June 30, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Laura Pfister
"Very professional to work with! Fixed my issue fast and followed up until all was good."
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Laura, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency providing prompt, courteous and efficient customer service is our top priority. We truly appreciate you choosing us for your insurance needs and look forward to continuing to serve you with care and dedication."
K McCarthy
June 17, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by K McCarthy
"I recently lost my husband and he had life insurance through State Farm. Matt Benincasa was the representative that I worked with through this unthinkable time in mine & my sons lives. If there ever was a silver lining through any of this it was Matt. He made the process so easy so that I could focus on trying to deal with the impossible. He truly was a gift from God. He gathered all of the paperwork for me to sign, talked me through everything that I was signing, kept me updated on what was happening as it was processing and showed compassion each and every step of the way. Matt Benincasa is definately my agent and he should be yours as well. I guarantee you’ll be just as happy as I am. Thank you again Matt for everything you did for the boys and me, from the bottom of my heart. — Kelly McCarthy"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Kelly, for your heartfelt review. In a time of such pain and suffering the fact that you took the time to leave this review is truly incredible! Please know that our thoughts and prayers are with you and your boys. As the father of two boys myself, I can only imagine your pain and grief. I am so happy that Matt was able to help you. This is what we are here for and this is when it matters the most. Please know that Matt, myself and the entire team are here for you always. We will continue to pray for you and your family. "
Al Comeau
June 12, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Al Comeau
"Joe took the time to personally make sure I was properly covered and the right price. I’ve been a customer for over 10 years and can’t imagine it any other way."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Al, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! We value you and your business and thank you very much for allowing us to service your insurance needs. My team and I at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency are here for any questions you may have at any time!"
Sarish Shehzadi
June 10, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Sarish Shehzadi
"Fabulous people to work with . I highly recommend Joe and his team especially Fabrianna. Joe and Fabrianna answered thoroughly each and every question I had in no wait time whether that was by phone, text or email. I am pleased with the service and professionalism that was extended to us."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Sarish, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency customer service is our number one priority. We are thrilled that you found our service to be five star worthy, professional, and up to your standards. Please know that Fabrianna, myself and the entire team are here for you always!"
Bright Varghese
May 28, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Bright Varghese
"I had a quick and painless experience with Fabrianna here at State Farm. She took the time to walk me through each line item of my new policy quote as well as provided detailed explanations to every one of my questions. She made it easy to switch my policy over and I am saving a chunk of money on my home and auto policies! Thank you Fabrianna and the State Farm team for a wonderful and pleasant experience!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Bright, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! Fabrianna is a very valued team member at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency and we thank you for the opportunity to earn your trust and deliver both savings and peace of mind through the right coverage. We value your business and look forward to being here for whatever you may need. "
Samantha Meliso
May 18, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Samantha Meliso
"I called Joe on a Saturday needing help with my insurance, and he answered right away. He was incredibly responsive, professional, and got everything taken care of quickly. Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Samantha, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency customer service is our number one priority. We greatly appreciate you and your business (and your whole family's too!) My team and I are here for you whenever you need us!"
matt borkowsky
May 16, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by matt borkowsky
"The process was very easy and smooth. Kathy Licona was extremely responsive and answered all of our questions clearly."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Matt, for taking the time to leave us a review. We greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer service is our number one priority. We’re thrilled that you found Kathy’s service to be five star worthy. Kathy, myself and the entire team are here for you with any questions you may have and for all of your insurance needs."
Devon Liguori
April 30, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Devon Liguori
"Joanne is one of the most kind and compassionate people I have met! Such a pleasure to work with!"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Devon, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer and community service are our main priorities. Joanne, myself and the entire team are here for you and your team always! "
Justin Castle
March 28, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Justin Castle
"Fabrianna takes the time to explain my policy options, making sure I have the right coverage for my home and auto. The rates are competitive, though they’ve increased a bit over time—but that seems to be the case with most insurance companies. Overall, I appreciate the personalized service and the peace of mind knowing I’m covered by a reputable provider and an agent who's response time is quick whenever I have a questions... Thanks Fabrianna! Highly recommend!"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Justin, for taking the time to leave us a review. In a world with so many choices, we greatly appreciate you entrusting your insurance needs with us at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency. Fabrianna and I and the whole team are here for you always."
Joe Taormina
March 28, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Joe Taormina
"Fabrianna Restani was very helpful, professional and knowledgeable. A pleasure to work with. Thank you"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Joe, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency customer service is our main priority. We are thrilled that Fabrianna was able to help you with all of your insurance needs. We thank you for your business and are here for you always!"
Luisa Alzate
March 27, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Luisa Alzate
"Best guilty there is! So pleased to have worked with them and get a great quote for my engagement ring. Now I feel at ease knowing my ring is insured. Thank you for the quick responses, for making it so easy and helpful with all the questions I had!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Luisa, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency customer service is our number one priority. We are thrilled that you found our service to be five star worthy. Congratulations on your engagement and please know that my team and I are here for you always!"
Dave Saul
March 19, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Dave Saul
"Joseph Benincasa State Farm is THE BEST!! We not only have contacted them for many different policies, but also referred them to many friends- also Happy!! And in addition; I know Both Joe and Joanne are extremely beloved in the local community; always there to help anyone and every event! In fact I see Joanne was even voted Businessperson of the year! Joseph Benincasa State Farm = 5+ Stars!!"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Dave, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! The greatest compliment is a referral so for that we thank you very much. At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency we are all about service, community and philanthropy. We are honored to have our business in this great town of Farmingdale and are grateful to all of our local customers for entrusting us with their insurance needs!"
apoorva bangera
March 19, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by apoorva bangera
"Joanne helped me to get my homeowners insurance! I got the best quote and everything was super easy. Recommend them to everyone. Fabrianna and Jamie helped me through the entire process, thank you!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Apu, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency our number one priority is customer service. We are thrilled that you found the team to be super helpful. We thank you for your business and please know that we are here for you always for all of your insurance needs! "
Stephen Preziosi
March 19, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Stephen Preziosi
"Joe Benincasa and his team are amazing. They saved me over $5,000 a year on insurance by giving me a better rate on my car insurance and my homeowners insurance. Not only did they save me money but they are prompt, courteous, and the best people to deal with. Thanks Joe."
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Stephen, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, our main priority is customer service and satisfaction. We are thrilled that we were able to save you money on your home and auto insurance. We thank you for entrusting us with your insurance needs. "
Queen Brown
February 20, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Queen Brown
"Joe and Joanne from State Farm Insurance are phenomenal insurance agents. They've worked extremely hard to get me the best policy, that's conducive to my needs. Both Joe, Joanne, and Fabrianna are effective communicator via email, phone, and text, who goes above and beyond to ensure that your thoughts, and concerns are addressed accordingly. They are patient, and courteous people, whom I would recommend to anyone that needs home and/or vehicle insurance."
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Queen, for taking the time to leave us a review. In a world with so many choices, we greatly appreciate you entrusting us with your insurance needs. Joanne, Fabrianna, myself and the entire team are here to assist you with any questions or concerns you may have. The greatest compliment is a recommendation, so for that we thank you very much. "
Joseph Sonnichsen
January 27, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Joseph Sonnichsen
"Jamie helped me with my policy, she was polite, knowledgeable and extremely helpful, without her help I probably wouldn’t have changed insurances"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Joseph, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! Jamie is a very valued team member at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency and we are thrilled that she was able to help you with your insurance needs. In a world with so many choices, we greatly appreciate you and your business!"
Aida Iannacci
January 22, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Aida Iannacci
"Fabrianna is an absolute pleasure to work with. She constantly kept in touch via email and phone calls. Looking forward to working with Fabrianna again soon"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Aida, for taking the time to leave us a review. Fabrianna is a very valued team member at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency and we are thrilled that she was able to help you with your insurance needs. We appreciate you and your business; please know that my team and I are here for you always!"
Lydia Balzano
January 22, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Lydia Balzano
"I was referred to this particular State Farm Ins Agency. Joseph Benincasa and his office were easy to contact, always returned calls and very friendly. I worked with Fabrianna and she was absolutely a pleasure to work with!"
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Lydia, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it. We are thrilled that Fabrianna was able to help you with all of your insurance needs. My team and I are here for you always!"
Lorraine Pasieka
December 17, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Lorraine Pasieka
"Been with Joe for years. Just added a car Kathy Licona assisted me. She was thorough & professional . I appreciate the ease in getting this done."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Lorraine, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer service is our number one priority. I’m so happy that Kathy was able to take care of your insurance needs. In a world with so many choices, please know that we greatly appreciate you and your business and my team and I are here for you always."
Mya Chae
December 10, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Mya Chae
"We had an excellent experience working with Matt Benincasa. As first-time homebuyers, we were unfamiliar with the homeowners insurance (HOI) process and had several questions. Matt was incredibly helpful, taking the time to explain everything in detail. He made the entire process smooth and stress-free for us."
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Mya, for taking the time to leave us a review. At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer service is our #1 priority. We are thrilled that you found Matt's service to be 5 star worthy. He and I, and the entire team, are here for you always! We thank you for your business!"
Barbara Ventura
November 28, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Barbara Ventura
"Joseph and Joanne Benincasa and staff are truly wonderful to work with. They are available when you need and treat you like family! As a realtor I refer them to my family and friends."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Barbara, for taking the time to leave us a review: we greatly appreciate it! We value you and your clients and appreciate you entrusting us with their insurance needs. At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency our number one priority is always customer service."
Desiree Woodson
November 27, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Desiree Woodson
"“I can’t say enough great things about Joanne and Matt at State Farm! From start to finish, they were professional, patient, and truly went above and beyond to meet my needs. The two of them made the process seamless, breaking everything down in a way that was easy to understand while offering tailored options that perfectly fit all the residents situation. Their attention to detail and genuine care for their clients are unmatched—I felt like more than just another customer. If you’re looking for exceptional service and a team that truly has your best interests at heart, I highly recommend Joanne, Matt, and the entire State Farm Insurance family. Thank you for making everything so stress-free and efficient!”"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Desiree, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency our number one priority is customer service. Thank you so much for entrusting us with your insurance needs. We are here for you always."
MARK LAYBURN
November 6, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by MARK LAYBURN
"Kathy Licona Was Professional, courteous, and a pleasure to work with, Thank you for all your help, Kathy."
We responded:
"Thank you very much, Mark, for taking the time to leave us a review. Kathy is a very valued team member at The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency where customer service is our #1 priority. We greatly appreciate you and your business. "
Bob Murawski
November 5, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by Bob Murawski
""I recently had an outstanding experience with Joe Benincasa State Farm Insurance office. Fabrianna went above and beyond to ensure I fully understood my coverage options and helped me find the best policy to meet my needs. Throughout the process, she was incredibly responsive, patient, and thorough in answering all my questions. I felt truly valued as a client, which is rare these days. Joe Benincasa and team made what can often be a confusing and stressful process straightforward and stress-free. I highly recommend Joe Benincasa State Farm Insurance and his team to anyone looking for a reliable, knowledgeable, and caring insurance professional!""
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Bob, for taking the time to leave us a review. At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer service and satisfaction is our number one priority. We are thrilled that you found Fabrianna‘s service to be five star worthy. In a world with so many choices, we truly appreciate you entrusting your insurance needs with us. Fabrianna, myself and the entire team are here for you always!"
matt feeney
October 31, 2024
5
out of
5
rating by matt feeney
"Had a great experience with John Stevens. He reached out early in the year but I wasn’t ready. He asked permission to follow up later in the year before my policy renewed. He did exactly what he said he would, and saved me around $1400 from my then current carrier. Easy change over. Great customer service overall. Thanks!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Matt, for taking the time to leave us a review; we greatly appreciate it! At The Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency, customer service is our #1 priority. We work hard to ensure that our customers are maximizing their discounts and we are here to work with them to explain, educate and be a resource. With so many choices in the insurance industry today, we thank you very much for choosing us. My team and I are here for you always!"